Pretty far west into Chelsea, there is a new resteraunt called Meatoast. Meatoast makes 12 inch subs (think a Kosher Quizno's that uses a panini press). I got a 6 inch sub (not on the menu but I convinced them that if they did not give me a 6 incher it would be Bal Tashlit and the Kashrut of the resteraunt would be questionable) with turkey, salami, letace, tomatto, pickles, and garlic mayonaise. I was not expecting anything to out of this world but the flavors literally exploded in my mouth. This was definitely the best sandwich that I have ever had in the United States. Thank you Meatoast for making meat amazing!
Please note- Meatoast is open Sunday through Thursday 10am-3/4 am, Friday 10 am -3 pm and Saturday 8pm-10AM... that's right, 24 hours straight until the week begins. They are cash only but seeing as a 12 inch sub is less than $10 that shouldn't be to hard.
MeaToast
(212) 239-7464
Chelsea 503 W 28th St
New York, NY 10001
*****